Introduction
I'll have to go on record at the outset, here, and say that I think James Cameron's TITANIC is a fantastic motion picture, and earned every one of the Academy Awards it won. This has turned out to be an unpopular opinion to hold about the most popular movie of recent (if not all-) time; the usual cynical backlash -- against anything that has garnered the kind of mega-success that Cameron's oceanic epic did -- has made praising TITANIC a risky endeavor. "I liked TITANIC," has to be qualified in conversation, to avoid embarrassment: I kind of liked it. It was okay. I enjoyed it, sort of; straightforward assertions as to its genuine, even superlative, quality as film entertainment is hard to make amid a chorus of "TITANIC sucks," and "I hated that movie," or plain old groans of disbelief. In the relative privacy of my office, writing these essays about Cameron's filmography, I feel free to aver my opinion that TITANIC is terrific; more, I can wade through the movie, scene by scene, and explain why.
Conversely, some critics of TITANIC are unable to explain why, except maybe to blame "the hype." What strikes me about this position is that TITANIC's hype was generated by the moviegoing public; it came from people who went to see it, loved it, told their friends, and went again -- and again. I myself saw it three times during its theatrical run, which is the highest compliment I pay to a movie when it's in the theaters. The compliment is especially high in this case, as watching TITANIC requires a considerable investment of one's time; I considered them to be well-spent hours. The hype came after the release. It is actually the case that the pre-release "hype" for TITANIC was all negative, for almost a year. Unheard-of production costs, breaking the head-spinning $200 million mark, requiring the support of two movie studios (Fox and Paramount); reports of Cameron's fanaticism (and fascism) and obsession with detail; release delays (originally scheduled and promoted as a summer movie, it was not released until November); and anything else bad you could possibly predict. TITANIC, for a long time, looked like it was going to be the biggest money loser of all time. It was going to be CLEOPATRA (1963) all over again, for the beleaguered 20th Century Fox, which was nearly sunk by that other, notoriously lavish, historical epic.
A remarkable thing happened, then. Harry Knowles of aintitcool.com received a report from a test screening in which the audience response went through the roof. Knowles, seen as something of an enfant terrible by Hollywood studios, who had been bitten badly by his advance reports and sneak-preview spies on many occasions, in this case had to eat their hats: Knowles' report was the first good hype for TITANIC; more than that, it was the first to predict that Cameron had come up with something of a miracle; that TITANIC was going to be an enormous success. It was. That the movie recouped its costs and made money is impressive; that it found its own legs just because audiences loved it of their own accord, no hype or media blitz necessary, is mind-blowing.
How did it do it? What did it do? It did everything it set out to do, exactly right. Cameron's obsessiveness had in fact been in the service of crafting a nearly note-perfect entertainment on a grand scale. It had a love story that worked -- no mean feat on its own -- and it had jaw-dropping visuals that immersed us in history, eyewitnesses to an event that we would be hard pressed to so vividly imagine by simply reading accounts of it. Cameron, however, imagined it; he imagined it in grand scope and in great detail; and then, putting all his talent and skill to bear, found a way to print what he saw in his imagination on celluloid for audiences worldwide to simultaneously share. This is why I find TITANIC to be so terrific. It's inspiring, heroic filmmaking. Cameron made so many smart decisions and only a few, tiny missteps. The ratio of smart decisions and good ideas to bad ones is something like 200:1. Okay, maybe I'm exaggerating, but I'm truly and duly impressed. TITANIC should have sunk, but it sailed all the way to Oscar-sweeping glory, and into the lists of all-time box office champions. Wow.
My only disappointment, perhaps, is that we may have already seen the career pinnacle of a great filmmaker who is still, in my way of thinking, a relatively young man. Yes, for one moment, on one evening in March 1998, James Cameron was "King of the world!" -- but only for that moment. Allowing Cameron is somewhat embarrassing boast as a natural reaction to having achieved the full recognition of his peers for his genuine achievement (the Academy Awards often pass over box-office winners and audience favorites, just for the sake of some strange notion of artistic integrity; TITANIC was the exception to the rule), his ejaculatory choice of words strikes me as ironic, just because it's ironic when Jack (Leonardo DiCaprio) shouts it in the movie, standing on the prow of the ship that's destined to sink, taking his life along with it. (I have to say, though, that it is precisely this chilly foreknowledge on the part of the audience that gives the first half of the movie a lot of its eerie strength and heft. But I'll go more into that later.) Cameron's moment as cinematic King is over, but we've still got his movie, and it's still grand entertainment.
As the ever-reliable Cameron regular Bill Paxton puts it, "Are you ready to go back to TITANIC?" Let's take a walk through this movie, start to finish, and see if I can explain exactly what I like about it, and what I think Cameron's expertly canny decisions were at every stop along the way.
Structure and Pacing
Two related aspects that I like about TITANIC are the excellence of its structure and its pacing. It's a three-hour ride that doesn't waste a moment, for one thing; for another, it uses its length wisely -- in other words, its proportions are in balance. The sinking of the ship happens in something that almost approaches real-time; it fascinated me that after the ship struck the iceberg, it wasn't an instant disaster. The danger wasn't immediately apparent. In any event, this carefully staged part of the movie; building and building and building in excitement, thrills, and horror (and all Cameron has to do, smartly, is simply let it happen at this pace, the way it happened, and it's as stunning a ride as any fictional action film); this takes up something close to the entire second half of the film. What's left over is still something like an hour and a half -- enough time to plot out an entire movie story as merely the lead-up to the disaster. It's enough time to introduce all of the characters, have the two romantic leads fall in love at a reasonably unhurried pace, and consummate their relationship. If you're the romantic type who will go along with a good love story if it's presented to you (rather than the cynical type who will blow raspberries at the screen the whole time), you are all set up to really care about what's going to happen to the two lovers once the ship starts to sink. This, to me, is excellence in design, in screenplay story plotting, in approaching the challenge of properly filling a broad (3 hour) movie canvas.
As an aside, I noted that Roberto Benigni's LIFE IS BEAUTIFUL used pretty much the same structure with similar success.
I have more comments to make about the film's pacing and structure, and how it allows Cameron to take his time setting things up. Once the ship starts sinking, it's an unstoppable catastrophe and a guaranteed thrill-ride; the pre-iceberg sub-movie, so to speak, is what really interests me, because what it does is heighten the thrills and deepen our emotional connection to watching the disaster unfold. Well, of course, one might say; that's the proper way to do it, if you're going to do it. That's exactly my point, that Cameron knew exactly how to wring the most out of the historical material he based his movie on. He didn't miss a trick; I can only assume that he worked on the script for years beforehand, and went through ten to fifteen drafts before settling on the shooting script, which of course is tweaked by cast, director and crew during the process of principal photography. This is just guesswork based on the results, but I think TITANIC must have had a long gestation period. It is possible to get a great script in a rush (notably, the script for TERMINATOR 2), but I think this one shows the marks of having had time to mature and settle; for ideas that didn't belong to slough off in the refinement process. The underlying architecture is too well-proportioned and too robust -- for a three-hour movie -- to have been quickly drafted.